THE QUESTION
Why do people like filter bubbles?
Group cards you judge alike. Groups organise reading; they decide nothing.
closed · back to Actions
Viewing as guest. Enter a handle to join and take part.
Clusters form from similarity, names come last
Canonical order: link pairs of ideas you judge similar — links are symmetric (A~B is B~A; direction never matters) and a tie holds once 2 members make it.
why
Links are symmetric — A~B is B~A. Clusters are the groups that emerge from held ties, and only a formed cluster can be named, by a person. Your own links carry a ✕ to withdraw; you cannot remove someone else's. Clusters organise the wall and never gate the vote — two cards making the same CLAIM are a merge back in Clarify.
Links and names are made while Cluster is live; the steward’s ← reopens it.
Schools do not teach how to read a source
To be precise: this is about incentives, not anyone's character.
Nothing said yet.
unnamed cluster — name it if the group has a common thread, or leave it unnamed (2)
Correcting someone publicly makes them dig in harder
~ People choose the sou… · helddiscuss
People choose the sources that already agree with them
unnamed cluster — name it if the group has a common thread, or leave it unnamed (2)
Being wrong in front of people you know is worse than being wrong
~ People I know now liv… · held~ Where you live now pr… · held~ Disagreeing in public… · helddiscuss
People I know now live in two different versions of the same country
~ Being wrong in front … · held~ The same event is rep… · held~ Where you live now pr… · helddiscuss
unnamed cluster — name it if the group has a common thread, or leave it unnamed (2)
Every platform is a private space that behaves like a public one
~ Public broadcasters a… · helddiscuss
Public broadcasters are treated as one side rather than a floor
· not yet clustered (43)
Twenty years ago the same complaint was made about television
Everyone assumes the other side is more extreme than it is
~ A newsroom now costs … · held~ Loneliness makes onli… · held~ Public broadcasters a… · held~ Nobody trusts a corre… · held~ Certainty is more com… · helddiscuss
Nobody agrees on who should decide what is true
Platforms are where politics happens, but nobody elected them
~ Nobody has ever shown… · helddiscussing (1)
Nobody trusts a correction if it comes from the other side
~ Everyone assumes the … · helddiscuss
Subscription walls put good reporting behind a price and left the rest free
Reach is sold, so the loudest account is not the most representative
Certainty is more comfortable than accuracy, and cheaper
~ A newsroom now costs … · held~ Loneliness makes onli… · held~ Everyone assumes the … · held~ Outrage travels furth… · helddiscuss
The same event is reported as two different events
~ People I know now liv… · helddiscuss
Local newspapers closed and nothing replaced them
Local life is thinner, so national politics fills the space
~ People no longer meet… · helddiscuss
Where you live now predicts what you believe better than anything else
~ A newsroom now costs … · held~ Outrage travels furth… · held~ A feed has no edges, … · held~ The problem is not wh… · held~ Being wrong in front … · held~ People I know now liv… · helddiscuss
Schools do not teach how to read a source
The word 'misinformation' has become a way to dismiss people
~ The problem is not wh… · helddiscuss
Being informed is expensive in time and nobody budgets for it
~ Ranking optimises for… · helddiscuss
Cheap sincerity beats expensive accuracy, and always has
The people most online are the least representative
~ Disagreeing in public… · held~ Reach is sold, so the… · held~ It is not a bubble; m… · helddiscuss
Political parties benefit from the split and have no reason to fix it
People no longer meet anyone who disagrees with them in person
Disagreeing in public costs you socially, so most people stop
~ The people most onlin… · held~ It is not a bubble; m… · held~ Reach is sold, so the… · held~ A feed has no edges, … · held~ Being wrong in front … · helddiscuss
Ranking optimises for time spent, not for being informed
The feeling of being lied to came first; the bubbles came after
Regulation moves in years and the products change in weeks
The people building this were not asked whether it should exist
There is no shared set of facts to argue from any more
Arguments online end in blocking, not in agreement
Moderation happens after the reach has already happened
Half the accounts arguing about this are not people
Ad money rewards volume of attention, not quality of it
~ Ranking optimises for… · helddiscuss
It is not a bubble; most people are simply not interested in politics at all
There is no button anywhere that says 'show me what I am missing'
Recommendation systems are not inspectable from outside
We measure engagement because it is easy to measure, not because it matters
A newsroom now costs more than the advertising it can sell
~ Everyone assumes the … · held~ Where you live now pr… · held~ Certainty is more com… · held~ Loneliness makes onli… · held~ Local newspapers clos… · helddiscuss
Working from home removed the last place people argued across lines
Nobody has ever shown that shared facts produced agreement, even when we had them
The problem is not what people believe but that believing has become an identity
~ A feed has no edges, … · held~ Where you live now pr… · held~ The word 'misinformat… · helddiscuss
The cheapest content to make is content about other content
The institutions that used to arbitrate lost their authority for their own reasons
A feed has no edges, so you cannot tell what you are not seeing
~ Outrage travels furth… · held~ The problem is not wh… · held~ Where you live now pr… · held~ Disagreeing in public… · helddiscuss
Loneliness makes online belonging worth more than accuracy
~ Outrage travels furth… · held~ Everyone assumes the … · held~ A newsroom now costs … · held~ Certainty is more com… · helddiscuss
Outrage travels further than accuracy, so it is what gets made
~ Loneliness makes onli… · held~ A feed has no edges, … · held~ Where you live now pr… · held~ Certainty is more com… · helddiscuss
We remember the claim and forget that it was corrected